Italy Roundtable: Why I Write About Italy

by Jessica on May 3, 2011

by | May 3rd, 2011  

This month, I’m excited to announce the debut of a new writing partnership with some really fabulous Italy bloggers. We’re calling it the Italy Blogging Roundtable, and every month each of us will write a post on one theme, giving readers an opportunity to hear different voices than they might normally read. From me, you might typically get a travel advice take on the topic of the month – from some of the other writers, you may get a photo essay, a personal anecdote, or something else altogether.

The fine ladies around the Italy Blogging Roundtable with me are Gloria of At Home in Tuscany, Alexandra of ArtTrav, Melanie of Italofile, and Rebecca of Brigolante. For our inaugural Roundtable topic, the theme is “why I write about Italy.” You’ll find links to the other posts on the topic at the bottom – please read and enjoy all of them.

Why I Write About Italy

Ask someone who writes an Italy travel guide why she writes about Italy, and it’s nearly a guarantee that you’ll get one of two replies:

  • Oh, Italy’s just so inspiring! The views! The history! The food! The people! How could you not write about Italy? (Etcetera, ad nauseum, you get the idea.)
    …or…
  • It’s my job.

I have, at various points over the 4+ years I’ve been writing on WhyGo Italy, fluctuated between those two points – although I’m usually more in the former camp than the latter. But the question of why I write about Italy is no longer as simple as either of the options listed above. In fact, in some ways, I wonder if it ever was.


Parma church – photograph by Jessica Spiegel and may not be used without permission

Before starting WhyGo Italy, I had visited Italy several times and had already fallen quite in love with the country. Yes, it was partly due to all the stuff listed above – the history, scenery, food, etc. – but there was something more, something I couldn’t put my finger on at the time. I was, up until my first trip to Italy, a serial country-lover. Whatever place I’d visited last, that was the country I was most in love with. I went from being a New Zealand-ophile to an Anglophile to a Francophile, and probably would have continued in that vein if Italy hadn’t intervened. Since visiting Italy, I’ve been to Germany, Croatia, and Scotland, and I’ve been to England and France again, too – and nothing has “stuck” like Italy.

It’s probably fair to say that the reasons I remain so passionate about Italy after so many years and visits are likely the same reasons the country spoke to me in the first place, but that doesn’t make determining what those reasons are any easier. After all, every place I’ve been has history and beautiful scenery and lovely people. What makes Italy so different?

For many years, I didn’t have a satisfactory answer when someone asked me why I loved Italy. Everything I said sounded like every other person who’s ever come back from an Italy trip swooning. Until, that is, I let fly the first thing that came into my head, a response that surprised me then and surprises me still.

“What do you love so much about Italy?” asked a friend.

The chaos,” I replied.


Milan street – photograph by Jessica Spiegel and may not be used without permission

Chaos isn’t generally thought of as a positive thing. As a traveler, you’re already in unfamiliar territory, so the last thing you want is to think that the few rules you’ve learned about your new surroundings could be ignored at any minute and for no reason. As a potential expat (which is how I still fancy myself), you might know your home country’s system is broken but at least it’s a system you’re comfortable with – why leave it for a country you don’t know where the system is so screwy it defies explanation?

All of this ran through my head the instant I said “chaos,” and I think I’ve been trying to make sense of that answer – and my belief in it being the right answer – ever since then. What I’ve come to is this: Italy, through its uncertainty, teaches me patience. It teaches me to have a Plan B. It teaches me to think on my feet, to accept what I’m presented with, to let the tide carry me sometimes even if I don’t know where I’m going because occasionally it carries me somewhere delightful. I have taken great leaps of faith in Italy, and – as a result – I take them more often when I’m not in Italy, too, which is completely the opposite of my character.

Now, the writing I do on WhyGo Italy is, for the most part, like an instruction manual for the country. I’m not usually writing about my experiences with those delightful places the tide has taken me, or my struggles with Italian chaos, but rather trying to categorize that chaos into something useful for others. The reason I do that is a simple one – I want travelers in Italy to have their expectations set appropriately so they can enjoy the best that Italy has to offer during their vacations without letting frustrations over things they can’t control ruin their trips. If I can help people be better prepared to deal with the occasional inexplicable problems that will arise (no matter how much planning you do), then perhaps Italy will be able to teach them a bit of patience, too.

I can’t promise serendipity, but I can certainly point the way and provide a flashlight.


Naples piazza – photograph by Jessica Spiegel and may not be used without permission

Other Voices from the Italy Blogging Roundtable

To find out how the other bloggers in this group tackled the statement “why I write about Italy,” click on the links below – read, enjoy, leave comments, and come back next month for another roundtable round-up.


{ 8 comments }

fd May 4, 2011 at 11:33 am
Corner

Always a pleasure to read your articles.
Just one thing: the photo of Milan you’ve posted is misleading :) (I’m just being tongue in cheek ) …Not all streets in Milan are like that, are they ?

Corner

Jessica May 5, 2011 at 11:05 am
Corner

Ah, that photo is from one of my favorite parts of Milan, the Brera – and it was on a rainy day when the light was lovely. Also, I’ve adjusted the color a bit and made it softer. Of course, the same can be said of those picturesque cobbled streets from (for instance) Siena – not all the streets in Siena are like that, either!

;)

Corner

fd May 5, 2011 at 11:57 am
Corner

I got it !
(Great snap though ! Brava ! )

Corner

Jessica May 5, 2011 at 1:03 pm
Corner

Grazie! :)

Corner

Rebecca Winke May 8, 2011 at 11:59 am
Corner

I LOVED the bullet points. Cracked me up.

Corner

Jessica May 9, 2011 at 10:48 am
Corner

Ha! Thanks, Rebecca. :) I’m sure there’s more nuance between those two points, but those are certainly the two ends of the spectrum I usually hear…

Corner

Danni88 May 10, 2011 at 12:39 am
Corner

Great snap.

Corner

Adam April 24, 2012 at 9:46 am
Corner

Hi Jessica,

Great thought-process there, turning chaos into something positive. I find that Brazil and Italy have a lot in common, chaos included. As an aside, this is also why I like computers, they taught me to be flexible in my approach towards the same goal. Many approaches for one goal. In Brazil, this general idea is called “dar um jeito” (to find a way). I believe Italian has “l’arte di arrangiarsi” which shares some similarities.

Corner

Comments on this entry are closed.

Previous post:

Next post: