First Class vs. Second Class on Italy Trains

by Jessica on July 16, 2008

by | July 16th, 2008  


Because I work for a company that sells Eurail passes, and because I used to do customer service for said company, I often get asked, “Is buying a first class train pass really worth the difference in price?” So I thought I’d throw my two cents on this issue into an article here, as my most recent European train experiences are all on Italian trains.

In general, when I’m asked whether there’s enough of a difference between first class and second class on European trains to justify the added cost, I say no, there isn’t. This is partly due to my overall feeling that the vehicle is the same whether I’m paying for first class or second class, so it’s getting me there at the same speed. (It’s this rationale that will, regardless of how much smaller they keep making coach seats, probably keep me from ever paying for first class airfare – I’m just a cheap airline tickets kind of girl.)

On my last trip to Italy, however, I rode the Eurostar between Milan, Florence, and Rome in first class, because that’s the rail pass I had. I did take note of a few first class perks which I wanted to share with you, but I still don’t think they’re enough to justify the price difference – whether you agree or not is another story!

First Class Trains in Italy

  • Wider aisles & seats
  • Fewer people
  • More luggage storage space
  • Free newspapers (some trains)
  • Free snacks & beverages (some trains)

 

Second Class Trains in Italy

  • Narrower aisles & seats
  • More people
  • Less personal space & space for luggage

 

In first class you can expect to share space with Italian business travelers and American tourists for the most part, while second class is more of a mix of all walks of life (including more frugal Italian business travelers and American tourists!). A trend on more and more trains these days is to have electrical outlets at nearly every seat, in both first and second class, so if you’ve got your electrical adapter/converter handy you can recharge your iPod or work on your laptop during your trip. It’s a great way to use the time when you’re moving from one place to another.

Some trains also have a dining car, but even this isn’t limited to just first class passengers – anyone can either get something from the dining car to eat back in their seat, or (if there’s a spot in the dining car available) stay there and eat a meal. And although there is sometimes a cart in first class that comes around (like on airplanes) with free newspapers and little bags of cookies, there are usually carts like that going through the second class cars as well – you’ll just have to pay for the goodies off those carts.

So, the biggest differences between first class trains and second class trains in Italy is going to be space – you’ll get more of it for yourself and for your bags in first class – and if you check out the prices of the different classes and it’s not much, then go for it. In some cases, it’ll be a significant difference, and that’s when you’ll have to decide whether those free crackers and hard candies are worth it.

>>Read more about Italy Railpasses before you go.

{ 5 comments }

Lisa April 13, 2009 at 6:58 pm
Corner

THANK YOU, finally, I got my question answered.(:

Corner

kirti August 31, 2009 at 11:37 am
Corner

thanks for the advice. i too feel the same way.

Corner

kirti August 31, 2009 at 11:41 am
Corner

i will be arriving in milan on the 10th september 09. i want to visit venice, florence and lake como. we are two friends from india. do you think its a better idea to buy a pass or just buy individual tickets ? will buying rail pass turn out to be cheap?

Corner

Jessica August 31, 2009 at 1:08 pm
Corner

Kirti, for the trips you’re taking, it’s not likely that a rail pass would be worth the price, unless you were taking the high-speed train from Venice to Florence and then from Florence to the lakes… But even then it might not be worth it. For shorter trips, or for slower trains, you’re almost always going to save money buying point-to-point tickets instead of a rail pass. You can read more about when it makes sense to buy a rail pass and when it doesn’t on the main train travel page here: http://www.italylogue.com/train/

Corner

Bob Domencetti January 3, 2013 at 8:26 am
Corner

My wife and I are planning a return trip to Rapallo sometime in the fall of 2013. We were planning on flying to Milan and taking the train to Rapallo. Questions: Is Milan the best place for as to fly into the country? Would it be best to just get a point-to-point ticket or rail pass? Would 2nd class work ?
Thanks for your advice.

Corner

Comments on this entry are closed.

Previous post:

Next post: